Tesla Model Y vs Nissan X-Trail: Running Costs in South Australia
Data verified April 2025
At this driving profile, the Nissan X-Trail is the more economical choice over 5 years in South Australia.
Running only 15,000 km per year in South Australia, the Tesla Model Y's higher purchase price doesn't fully pay back through lower running costs within 5 years. The Tesla Model Y costs $141,555 in total versus $81,423 for the Nissan X-Trail — a difference of $60,133. The numbers don't reach break-even within this holding period. If you drive significantly more km per year, or if petrol prices rise substantially, this comparison would shift. The Tesla Model Y still avoids around 5,147 kg of CO₂ over the ownership period.
The economics don't stack up at this driving distance — increase annual km or extend the holding period to change the picture.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Tesla Model Y cheaper than the Nissan X-Trail over 5 years in South Australia?
At 15,000 km/yr in South Australia the Nissan X-Trail is the cheaper option over 5 years: $81,423 total versus $141,555 for the Tesla Model Y. Use the calculator to adjust for your situation.
Does the Tesla Model Y break even against the Nissan X-Trail in South Australia?
At 15,000 km/yr in South Australia the Tesla Model Y does not fully recover its price premium within a 5-year holding period. Higher annual km or an extended holding period would change this.
How much does it cost to charge the Tesla Model Y vs fuel the Nissan X-Trail per year in South Australia?
At 15,000 km/yr in South Australia, charging the Tesla Model Y costs approximately $1,244/yr, versus $1,757/yr in petrol for the Nissan X-Trail. South Australia's electricity and fuel rates are applied automatically.